Fresh Baked to Order

Order Online

Pick your tray, choose your flavors, and check out — Tara will bake fresh for you.

  • Pick your tray & flavors
  • 3–5 days notice needed
  • Pickup or local delivery
  • Baked fresh just for you

Cookie Trays

Everything is made to order in small batches. Choose a tray size below, pick your flavors, and add to cart. Tara will reach out to confirm your bake date and pickup or delivery details.

Great for gifting

Small  (24ct)

2 dozen $20.00

Perfect for a personal treat, small gathering or party.

Order this size
Most popular

Medium (48ct)

4 dozen $30.00

The sweet spot — enough to share at the office, a family dinner, or school event.

Order this size
Party ready

Large (60 ct)

6 dozen $50.00

Made for parties, showers, and holidays.

Order this size
Assorted homemade cookie tray in festive holiday packaging

Add to Your Order

Select a product below to choose your size, flavor, and quantity — then add to cart.

All treats are baked fresh to order. Please allow 3–5 days notice. Tara will confirm your bake date, pickup, or delivery details after checkout.

Tara's Sweet Creations

Small-batch cookie trays and made-to-order treats — baked with care in Tara's home kitchen for birthdays, showers, and everyday celebrations.

Ordering & pickup

© 2026 Tara's Sweet Creations · Baked with love, one small batch at a time